Get in touch
555-555-5555
mymail@mailservice.com
  • 116 Public Square, PO Box 627, LaGrange, OH 44050

OHIO'S TOP-RATED INDEPENDENT

INSURANCE AGENCY

Bellwether Insurance is an independent insurance agency that provides customized insurance solutions with personalized service. It is our goal to make sure you, your family, your property and your business are properly insured at a reasonable price.

ABOUT BELLWETHER INSURANCE

Discover how Bellwether Insurance can protect you

Bellwether Insurance is an independent insurance agency that provides customized insurance solutions with personalized service. It is our goal to make sure you, your family, your property and your business are properly insured at a reasonable price.

We started Bellwether Insurance in 2016 on the premise of providing the type of service we expect from the businesses we deal with daily in our personal lives. We believe in providing every client with personalized service rooted in the following core values:

  • HONESTY
  • INTEGRITY
  • COURTESY
  • TIMELINESS

216-600-2828

Speak with a Bellwether Agent Today!

OUR PERSONAL INSURANCE COVERAGE IN OHIO

Explore Personal Insurance Coverage in Ohio

We only work with outstanding insurance companies that offer great value and continually impress our clients.


Home Insurance

Protecting Ohio homes, ensuring comfort


Life Insurance

Safeguard futures, cherish moments


Umbrella Insurance

Extra coverage, ultimate peace


Car Insurance

On the road, confidently insured


Condo & Renters Insurance

Customized policies, worry-free living


Motorcycle Insurance

Ride fearlessly, enjoy the journey

We shop the best insurance rates and coverage for you. Explore all services.

WHY WORK WITH BELLWETHER INSURANCE

Reasons to work with Bellwether Insurance

We only work with outstanding insurance companies that offer great value and continually impress our clients.

We strive to provide the lost art of customer service and focus on lifetime professional insurance management for our clients.

We offer that human touch. If a client gets in touch with us at any time via any method, they will be talking to us, not a machine.

We continually surprise our clients with our responsiveness, speed and ease of doing business.

OUR COMMERCIAL INSURANCE COVERAGE IN OHIO

Explore Business Insurance Coverage in Ohio

We strive to provide the lost art of customer service and focus on lifetime professional insurance management for our clients.


Business Owners (BOP) Insurance

Comprehensive coverage, safeguarding your business assets and operations


Professional Liability Insurance

Preserve your reputation, protect against negligence claims and lawsuits


Commercial Auto Insurance

Secure your fleet, cover liability and physical damage, drive with confidence


Cyber Insurance

Robust defense against cyber threats, data breaches, and digital risks


Contractors Insurance

Project protection, liability coverage, peace of mind for construction work


Commercial Package Insurance

Customized, all-in-one policy for diverse business needs, optimal protection

We shop the best insurance rates and coverage for you or your business. Explore all services.

OUR DEDICATED TEAM

Meet The People Behind Bellwether Insurance

Not all insurance agents are created equal. At Bellwether Insurance, we go out of our way to treat our clients like people and we use our industry experience and diversified knowledge base to protect what you value most in business and in life.

OWNER

Aaron McElwain, CIC

OWNER

Sandra McElwain

AGENT

Jessica Fox

AGENT

Christine Cuson

Customer Reviews & Testimonials

See what our insurance clients have to say about our coverage and service

I can't even begin to describe the remarkable service my family and I have received from Bellwether! I have always been hesitant to change my home and auto insurance but decided to give this company a chance, and I am glad I did! They saved me a lot of money on both my home and auto insurance and at the same time got us better coverage! I only had supply them with some information and they did the rest. It was very easy. They kept me up to date with what was going on and never made a step without contacting myself first! I would definitely recommend Bellwether!

Brenda G.

I highly recommend Bellwether Insurance! Sandra is amazing! She is quick to answer my questions and she finds me the best rates. She checks in on me to make sure that my needs are being met and followed me through my entire home buying process! Would highly recommend!


Rene B.

Absolute pleasure to work with. Sandra has taken care of all my insurance needs for over 2 years now. Bellwether was able to save me quite a bit of money over previous carrier. Always giving heads up on any changes, or weather it’s time to check for new price she’s on top of it. I recommend them often to friends and family.

Rob J.

I've been dealing with Jessica Johnston and she found me a deal that far exceeds the best policy State Farm offers for homeowner's insurance. (I've been a customer with SF for 22 years.) I had so many questions that Jessica received numerous calls and emails from me... all went answered in less than 15 minutes. She is always friendly and professional, and I have recommended her to people already!

Ashlynn S.

Industries Served


Choose Bellwether Insurance of LaGrange, Ohio for your business insurance needs and experience unparalleled service. Our commitment to partnering with only the best insurance companies ensures value and satisfaction for our clients. We take pride in providing exceptional customer service, focusing on lifetime professional insurance management. At Bellwether, you'll always be greeted by a friendly human touch, not a machine, and our dedication to responsiveness and efficiency consistently exceeds client expectations. Trust us to make your insurance experience seamless and stress-free.

ALL INDUSTRIES SERVED

Ohio Insurance Blog

Latest news & updates

What Happens When Your Subcontractor Causes an Accident in Ohio? Here’s How Insurance Can Protect Yo
14 Oct, 2024
Learn how to navigate subcontractor accidents in Ohio's construction industry. Understand liability, state laws, and the importance of proper insurance coverage
5 Common Insurance Claims Denied for Contractors in Ohio—And How to Avoid Each One
14 Oct, 2024
Learn the top 5 reasons contractor insurance claims are denied in Ohio and how to avoid them. Ensure proper documentation and coverage to protect your business.
How to Ensure Your Contractor Insurance Complies with Ohio’s State Regulations
14 Oct, 2024
Navigate Ohio's contractor insurance requirements with our guide. Ensure compliance with liability and workers' compensation coverage to protect your business.
How to Protect Your Business from Job Site Accidents: Essential Liability Insurance for Ohio Contrac
14 Oct, 2024
Protect your Ohio construction business with the right liability insurance to cover job site accidents, minimize risks, and safeguard against financial losses.
What is Assault and Battery Coverage, and why is it important for bars and taverns in Ohio?
13 Sep, 2024
Protect your Ohio bar or tavern with Assault and Battery Coverage. Safeguard against legal and financial fallout from incidents on your premises.
How Much Is Limo Insurance
By Insurance Content Writer 31 Aug, 2023
Protect Your Limousine Business with Bellwether Insurance: Learn about the significance of limo insurance and its role in safeguarding your luxury transportation venture. Explore factors influencing insurance costs, from limo type and driver experience to location and operating radius. Secure your business's future with comprehensive limo insurance coverage.
What You Should Do After a Motor Vehicle Accident in Ohio
By Insurance Content Writer 31 Aug, 2023
Stay informed after a motor vehicle accident in Ohio. Learn about reporting, laws, and steps for safety and protection. Get expert guidance from Bellwether Insurance.
Auto Insurance Discounts Worth Asking About in Ohio
By Insurance Content Writer 31 Aug, 2023
Drive Smart with Bellwether Insurance: Discover how to save on auto insurance in Ohio through a range of available discounts. From good driver incentives to safety equipment rewards, our comprehensive guide helps you understand how to qualify for and maximize these discounts, making your auto insurance more affordable while prioritizing safety on the road.
The Ultimate Guide to Renting Out a Condo in Ohio & What Insurance You Need
By Insurance Content Writer 31 Aug, 2023
Elevate Your Condo Rental Experience in Ohio: Explore the ins and outs of renting out your condo with Bellwether Insurance. From understanding the Ohio rental market to setting competitive prices and finding reliable tenants, our comprehensive guide has you covered. Ensure a successful and profitable condo rental venture with expert insights and tips.
Boat Insurance in Ohio
By Insurance Content Writer 31 Aug, 2023
Navigate Ohio's Waters with Confidence: Discover the importance of boat insurance for responsible boat ownership in Ohio. Learn about coverage options, legal requirements, and factors influencing the necessity of boat insurance. From protecting your vessel to ensuring peace of mind on the water, Bellwether Insurance has you covered.
Share by: