Bellwether Insurance reviews

All 84 of our Google reviews are five stars. Here's what Ohio families and business owners say about working with Aaron, Sandra, Jessica and Christine, in their own words.

5.0

84 reviews on Google

Leave a Google Review Read them on Google

Read every review

Here are the other 73 written reviews. Another 10 clients left a five-star rating without a comment.

Sandra has been more than helpful getting me the best policy for my home and auto needs. I highly recommend her.

Surj G.May 2026

Response from Bellwether

It is a pleasure working with you Surj! Thank you!

I worked with this company for my bar & restaurant. Christine was easy to work with. She took the time to get a premium to meet our needs. Highly recomend.

Dakota K.April 2026

Response from Bellwether

It's always a pleasure working with you Dakota! We look forward to all the great years ahead!!!

I worked very closely with Jessica, and she was fantastic. She explained all my current coverages and helped me understand what my new coverages would be. Bellwether Insurance is a very friendly and knowledgeable insurance company.

Lauren L.March 2026

Response from Bellwether

Thanks Lauren!!!! Very appreciated. We enjoy working with you!

Sandra does my Personal Insurance needs and Aaron does our business needs and all I can say is they are the most amazing and tentative people. My family has been dealing with them for years and I always find myself telling people to reach out to them.

Kati D.January 2026

Response from Bellwether

Thank you for the kind words Kati. It is our absolute pleasure to work with you and your family!

Sandra is an excellent communicator. She listens to you needs and do her best to meet your needs.

Vivian B.December 2025

Response from Bellwether

It was a pleasure to work with you Vivian! Thank you!

Sandra and Aaron worked with me on a very tight timeline to get the coverage that I need at a better price than anyone else was able to offer. Everyone I spoke with at Bellwether took the time to listen to and understand my needs. I highly recommend for anyone that is needing better insurance coverage than the big commercial companies.

James S.August 2025

Response from Bellwether

James, It was our pleasure to help insure your new home build. Congratulations and thank you for choosing us!

I cannot recommend the team at Bellwether enough! By far the very best experience that I have ever had with an insurance company.

Natalie Z.July 2025

Response from Bellwether

Thank you, Natalie! It's a pleasure!

Aaron has been a pleasure to work with. He’s fantastic at time management, communication and getting things done in a timely manner. Very easy to work with and informative across the board. I highly recommend him.

Donald H.June 2025

Response from Bellwether

Thanks Don!! It's a pleasure working with you as well!!

Bellwether Insurance has provided my husband and me with excellent service for Homeowners and Auto Insurance. Agent Aaron McElwain offered excellent guidance in meeting our coverage requirements and understanding our policies. When my husband passed away, Aaron and Bellwether Insurance assisted me with understanding my insurance options and changing needs. My questions and concerns are addressed promptly and thoroughly.

Bellwether Insurance was recommended to us by a friend at a time when we needed new insurance policies, and I have never regretted the choice we made. I heartily pass along the recommendation!

Karen W.June 2025

Response from Bellwether

You are the best Karen. We love working with you!

Some of the best folks i have ever gotten to work with. Sandra especially helped me through the whole process and got me an amazing rate and kept in constant communication the whole time! Highly recommend using these folks to get your home and Auto Insurance needs taken care of!! Thank you all once again!

D G.May 2025

Response from Bellwether

Dylan, it was my pleasure to help you through the process! Congratulations on your new home!

Christine was very understanding and patient with me as a new business owner, and offered lots of guidance in my search for insurance. Highly recommend.

Cora H.April 2025

Response from Bellwether

Thank you for the kind review Cora! It was my pleasure assisting you with your insurance needs. I wish you the best in your new business venture.

Sandra was wonderful to work with!

Rhonda B.April 2025

Response from Bellwether

Thank you for the kind words Rhonda. I am looking forward to working with you for years to come!

Sandra was great always in contact and fast thank you

Dustin H.April 2025

Response from Bellwether

Dustin, it was a pleasure working with you. Thank you!

Sandra and Bellwether Insurance were absolutely incredible to work with, and got me incredible rates on both my home and my vehicles. Sandra is the only one I would recommend for anyone looking for insurance!

James B.April 2025

Response from Bellwether

Wow, thank you so much James! It was a pleasure. Enjoy your new home!

Sandra at Bellwether Insurance was a delight to talk with and very helpful. She answered all of my insurance questions and I feel she was really looking out for what my family needed in terms of car and Home Insurance and was very timely.

Laurie R.March 2025

Response from Bellwether

Thank you for your kind words, Laurie. It was my pleasure and I'm so happy I was able to help!

Aaron at Bellwether insurance was absolutely phenomenal! He was able to get me great coverage for my business at an amazing rate. Very professional and very prompt with everything, could not have asked for a better experience. Absolutely recommend!

Mike R.March 2025

Response from Bellwether

Thanks Mike!!!! We are excited to have you with us!

I simply could not be happier with the professional and warm treatment in the Bellwether office by the amiable husband and wife team, Sandra and Aaron. The custom insurance plan they created for my deceased father's home, as well as covering his widowed wife, was exactly what the family needed for peace of mind and security. I think my favorite aspect of their business approach is the video messages that are included with itemized proposals. It's like being in their office from the comfort of your own home as they walk you through the documents, step-by-step, and answering every conceivable question that may arise. And finally, in a followup phone call, tying up any loose ends and putting me (the client) in a positive, confident frame of mind. it was honestly the most stress-free process I've been through in the past year and that includes trying to figure out the byzantine structure that is Medicare and dealing with a different insurance company after my car was totaled. If they allowed six stars I would have happily clicked it!

Jim G.February 2025

Response from Bellwether

Jim, it was a pleasure working with you and knowing we were able to give you peace of mind is exactly what we strive for. Thank you for the opportunity!

They made it easy to switch over my insurance, was very helpful and did not try to oversell me. Couldn’t be happier.

Homer L.February 2025

Response from Bellwether

Thanks Homer!!! We appreciate the shout out!

I worked with Jessica Fox to get General Liability for my remodeling company. She is a consummate professional who got me a competitive quote the same day and smoothly handled all the billing details. Great communication and incredibly responsive customer service. I'll be moving my other business in Ohio over to this agency.

LJJanuary 2025

Response from Bellwether

Thank you, Dashiell! It is our pleasure. I look forward to working with you.

We were looking for a company that could handle our specific insurance needs as most are limited. We had a fantastic experience at Bellweather Insurance and decided to switch to them as our old carrier could not do what we needed, in addition we added more and saved us even more than we expected. The team at Bellweather Insurance great to deal with and very knowledgeable and understanding of our situation and needs, we are glad we switched.

K P.January 2025

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Kalman!!

As a gig worker, having the right insurance is a fundamental element for the success of my business. I was drawn to Bellwether due to their comprehensive web site and Jessica was incredibly helpful in providing me with the best options to ensure that I had the appropriate coverage. Jessica was also successful in creating great solutions for my Personal Insurance needs as well. I could not recommend a better agency.

Chris P.December 2024

Response from Bellwether

Thank you, Chris!!

Sandra was very helpful in finding our family a better rate with the all the coverage we have carried with a competitor company over the last few years.

Sandra responded quickly, and was very easy to work with. Very much appreciate her help and would recommend Sandra and Bellwether insurance.

TaraNovember 2024

Response from Bellwether

Tara, I'm so happy you're pleased! It was my pleasure to help. Thank you!

Sandra at Bellwether was able to help me with a difficult situation. She has been kind, professional,and prompt. She said she would get back to me in x amount of days. She got back to me before that day and with a very helpful video presentation . She has answered all questions with complete and honest answers. I am very grateful to have her as my agent.

Josephine C.September 2024

Response from Bellwether

Josephine, it was my pleasure to be able to help. Thank you for your kind words!

The team at Bellwether Insurance was fantastic !

Needed business liability insurance and equipment coverage and had been waiting for over a week for other agencies to get back with quotes ……..got with Jessica at Bellwether Insurance and she got me fixed up with everything I needed in about 2 hours!

Thanks for making the whole process simple and easy you have earned a customer for life and I will be bringing all my insurance business their way

Mitch R.August 2024

Response from Bellwether

Thank you, Mitch!!

Excellent experience working with agent and staff to meet our insurance needs.

Gregory F.August 2024

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Gregory!! It is a pleasure working with you and Paula!!

We were looking for an insurance company that would be available to answer all our questions and to be there when we need them and Bellwether answered all our needs. I highly recommend them!

Colleen D.December 2023

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Colleen!

Aaron and Jessica did an amazing job helping find coverage and discounts, I highly recommend them for all of your insurance needs!

Deanna K.December 2023

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Dee!!!!

Thank you to Aaron and the entire team at Bellwether!! Great customer service is a rare thing these days 🙂

SaltydogAugust 2023

Response from Bellwether

Very welcome!

Jessica Fox at Bellwether ins was amazingly helpful - fast - and most importantly very welcoming and supportive. Extra added bonus — She saved me over $100 a month!!!

Marie S.July 2023

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Marie! I am so glad that I was able to help and I look forward to being your agent for the years to come!

We were searching for new home and Auto Insurance and reached out to Jess at Bellwether to help us find the right insurance for our needs at the right price and she delivered! She was so knowledgeable, thoughtful and easy to work with - she took care of everything. We are busy parents & professionals and she made it so easy for us to get quickly onboarded to our new insurance and she took care of notifying all the appropriate parties of our changes. I highly recommend her and Bellwether.

Kelly C.July 2023

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Kelly! It is my pleasure to be your agent 🙂 -Jessica

Absolutely the best! Jessica is very nice and easy to work with and very responsive!

Guts G.June 2023

Response from Bellwether

Thank you so much Tiffany! I am so happy to be your agent! -Jessica

They are an awesome team! Sandra was so helpful and went above and beyond in every step of the process!!

Jenna L.June 2023

Response from Bellwether

Thanks for the review, Jenna! We wish you the very best in your new home!!!

After a decade old relationship with a premium and Commercial Insurance provider.. my switch to Bellwether has left me wondering why I waited so long. Primarily my experience has been dealing with Jessica Fox.. and she's been awesome to work with. She's super responsive, stays on top to follow up on your enquiries and really gets things done to delight customers.

Arun K.April 2023

Response from Bellwether

Thank you, Arun! It's an absolute pleasure to work with you. Your kind words are much appreciated, and I look forward to being your agent for the years to come. -Jessica Fox

I can't begin to tell you how reassuring it is to have someone always looking out for you. Bellwether is always saving me money and improving my coverage. And, they do this without me prompting them. I highly recommend them for all your insurance needs!

Brian O.August 2022

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Brian!

Jessica was amazing to work with. Very knowledgeable and professional. She took the time to explain coverage, answer questions and get a few deductible options. And she saved us money while increasing coverage.

Sheri C.August 2022

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Sheri!

I highly recommend Bellwether Insurance! Jessica has been great to work with. Not only did she help us save a bunch on our home, auto, and umbrella policies, she helped us identify some areas where we were lacking in coverage. So, we are paying less and have better coverage!

Mark F.August 2022

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Mark!!

Bellwether Insurance, and particularly my agent Sandra McElwain, are outstanding. Sandra is incredibly responsive and prompt. I have moved a few times and Sandra has always been there to quickly make the necessary changes to my insurance, as well as for my elderly father. She completely removes all of the stress from the process. I highly recommend Sandra and Bellwether!

Scot H.May 2022

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Scot!! We appreciate working with you and your father!!!

Bellwether Insurance has been fabulous to work with. They are extremely helpful and personable. I don't know what I would do without them when it comes to our auto and Home Insurance. Thank you, Bellwether Insurance!

Mary T.May 2022

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Mary!!!! We really appreciate working with you!!

Very helpful with my questions about health insurance 🙂

Janet K.March 2022

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Janet! Happy to help!

Jessica was great to work with. She was very professional and informative throughout the whole process. Thank you!

Chris S.November 2021

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Chris!!!

Working the Aaron at Bellwether Insurance and the experience has been great. They are super responsive (even after hours) and were able to get me a great rate on insurance on my rental properties.

Derek F.July 2021

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Derek! It's a pleasure working with you!

I highly recommend Bellwether Insurance! Sandra is amazing! She is quick to answer my questions and she finds me the best rates. She checks in on me to make sure that my needs are being met and followed me through my entire home buying process! Would highly recommend!

Rene B.June 2021

Response from Bellwether

Thanks so much Rene! We really appreciate you!

When working with Sandra and her team at Bellwether Insurance, we knew immediately that we were getting the best care possible. Sandra has been working with our busy and constantly changing lives for almost two years now. From living in a condo, to a new home and new vehicles, she’s been absolutely amazing in helping us along the way. She’s saved me so much money and time while making it seem so effortless. We’re so pleased!

Hesham S.June 2021

Response from Bellwether

Thanks so much Hesham! It has been our pleasure to insure you and your family!

I could not recommend Bellwether more! Jessica helped me set up Home Insurance and also helped me bundle other insurance in to make my life easier. I will be recommending them to my family for all the insurance needs!

Joe P.May 2021

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Joe!!!

As an insurance agent myself, I’m very careful with whom I trust my risk management. I found everything that I was looking for with Sandra and Aaron. Not only do they meet all of my needs but they do it in an efficient and affordable way. I will always do business with them and highly recommend them to anyone.

Carrie J.May 2021

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Carrie! Coming from a colleague this means the world!

I have had nothing but the best experience with Bellwether insurance. Jessica and Sandra have taken great care of any of my needs. The response time and resolution time are awesome! I am so glad my loan officer, Dustin referred me to such a great company to work with.

Tiffany R.February 2021

Response from Bellwether

Thank you so much for the kind words Tiffany! We enjoy working with you!

I worked with Jessica Johnston and she has been absolutely amazing. Got us a great quote and worked out all our requests and preferences. Very quick to respond and answer any questions I had. Would definitely recommend to everyone. Thank you so much.

Yatzaira M.February 2021

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Yatzaira! We love our Jess and she said you are a pleasure to work with!!

This review is long overdue and I extend my apologies to them. Life has sent a few challenges this year.

My roof was hail damaged this past summer. I contacted the insurance company and was pleasantly surprised at their prompt response. The adjuster contacted me immediately and began the process. I was kept informed every step of the way by the adjuster and the agent.

In addition, a couple of months ago I had a sump pump failure (due to my neglect), and had to make another claim. I called the agent and the same process transpired as the one with my roof. When I changed to this company about a year and a half ago, the agent recommended I get water coverage. I’m so thankful for that. This claim was covered in full.

If anyone is considering changing insurance companies, I highly recommend you consider this one. The employees are both personal and professional. I know they have my best interest at heart. I am confident they treat every customer the same. They are a small town insurance company with Big City service. The best deal around in my opinion!

Thank you so much Sandra and Aaron! You’re the best!

Wishing you the most success!

Brenda

Brenda H.February 2021

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Brenda!!We appreciate the kind words!!

Wonderful to work with! Makes adding and removing insurance on things a breeze. Would suggest them to anyone who needs insurance.

Logann C.January 2021

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Logann!!! We appreciate working with you and Nate!!

I've been dealing with Jessica Johnston and she found me a deal that far excceeds the best policy State Farm offers for homeowner's insurance. (I've been a customer with SF for 22 years.) I had so many questions that Jessica received numerous calls and emails from me... all went answered in less than 15 minutes. She is always friendly and professional, and I have recommended her to people already!

Ashlynn S.December 2020

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Ashlynn! We agree, Jessica is a pro! We appreciate the shout out!

Bellwether Insurance is the best ever! Always there when I need them and always has the answers with quick replies. I will never go with a different Insurance Agent. If I could, I would give then a 10 Star review! Thanks Sandra for all your help!

Bobby P.December 2020

Response from Bellwether

Thanks Bobby! We're so happy to be able to help people like you! We appreciate your choosing us!

Bellwether Insurance has been great to have as our agent. They get us the lowest rate, correct coverage and deal directly with the insurance provider. Best insurance agents I have dealt with for the last 50 years!

Ralph M.October 2020

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Ralph! We work hard to ensure our clients are well taken care of and appreciate your kind words!

My wife and I were in a pinch with trying to close asap due to upcoming events and with progressive not providing the loan agency what they needed we had to find another insurance company and I am glad we found Sandra at Bellwether Insurance.

She understood our rush and did all she could to get us quoted and ready to close on her end.

10/10 would recommend.

Thanks again Sandra!

Clark B.October 2020

Response from Bellwether

Thanks so much Clark! It was a pleasure working with you and I'm glad I was able to help!

Absolute pleasure to work with. Sandra has taken care of all my insurance needs for over 2 years now. Bellwether was able to save me quite a bit of money over previous carrier. Always giving heads up on any changes, or weather it’s time to check for new price she’s on top of it. I recommend them often to friends and family.

Rob J.September 2020

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Rob!! We really appreciate you trusting us with your insurance needs!

Aaron and Sandra are amazing! I faithfully stayed with my previous insurance for over ten years until I had them review my policies. Wish I would have done it years ago. Saved me quite a bit of money as well as gaining coverage what's not to love? They respond very quickly and professionally. I work in sales as a profession so it's great to see that level of attention and attentiveness provided here. Stop your search and give them a shot you won't regret it. On a side note even though it is something so small I love the fact they send laminated copies of insurance cards anytime you make a change. 10/10

Nick W.July 2020

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Nick!

Great to work with, Jessica was very professional and made the whole process hassle free. Thank You again

Ronnie P.July 2020

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Ronnie!!

Bellwether Insurance helped me choose the best plan to meet all my needs and saved me money!!! They're easy to reach, even during off hours, and fast to return an answer.

Carey A.January 2020

Response from Bellwether

Having Aaron and Sandra as our agents has provided many benefits. They are responsive, and adaptive to our needs. They even went as far as to get licensed in a new state to remain our agents when we moved from Ohio to Arizona. Couldn't be more grateful to have them as our agents!

Kenny P.December 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Kenny! Have a great New Year!

We saved money going with Bellwether. I sent my dad, he saved money. They are friendly and professional and quick to respond to all inquiries. I highly recommend Bellwether insurance.

Mandy C.December 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Mandy!!

Aaron and Sandra McElwain at Bellwether Insurance are true professionals. Their product knowledge and attention to detail are top shelf. I am delighted to recommend them for all your insurance needs. If you would like the assurance of knowing your insurance is in place... ready should you need it and backed by a team of professionals... call them today.

Michael A.December 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Michael!

Not just an agent but a friend that looks out for your needs.

Michael K.December 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Nancy! We always enjoy seeing you guys!!

Sandra and her team are amazing!! Always help get the best rates and are very responsive to all your needs. 20/10!

Fady M.December 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Fady!

Your timely responsiveness and client's best interest (shopping for best rates without being prompted) are highly appreciated.

Gary M.December 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Gary!

Very easy to get ahold of and to meet in person. I walked out knowing I made a great deal. Would definitely recommend!

Courtney C.December 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Courtney! Our mission is to put the service back in the service industry!

We are so grateful for Aaron McElwain. My husband and I enjoy, family and fun. Aaron was able to cover our cars, motorcycles, boat and home with better policy protection at a WAY LOWER rate than what we were paying. We are so happy with the policies. If you are shopping rates this is the place!

Most importantly, when my son’s house had a devastating fire, Aaron supported, guided, made extra trips to house, communicated and advised my son through the whole complicated process. You can not find this personal connection just anywhere.

He makes himself accessible at any time and we consider him more family than insurance agent!

Sincerely,

Kim Kasicky

Kim K.November 2019

Response from Bellwether

Likewise Kim! Thank you so much! We love working with you guys and are very grateful that no one, not even the pet fish, were injured in that fire.

Aaron and Sandra are wonderful, caring people who support the community.

Lyn C.May 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Lyn!!

Aaron & Sandra will provide you with the best insurance experience. They always go above and beyond!!!

RonMay 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Ron!!!

The best experience you can possibly have purchasing and maintaining insurance. Aaron and Sandra take extremely good care of my house hold, and currently manage all of my policies including auto, home, plus all of my toys. Setup was a breeze and they handle all of the leg work. I cant say enough good things about the stress free experience and professionalism they provide. They are 100% honest with you and your explain the benefits and cost differences in coverage. Aaron deals with my (I'm sure annoying) constant change of cars, motorcycles and the like, and always is happy to do so for me at lighting fast speed. I'm so happy to finally not have to deal with incompetent mainstream insurance again and look forward to doing business with Bellwether for years to come!

AnthonyK89February 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Anthony! We love toys and love to share in the excitement!!!!

Best prices in town. Superior customer service. Above and beyond.

Denice H.February 2019

Response from Bellwether

Thank you Denice!!!

Aaron Insured our bar! We have awesome coverage at a great premium. He is always available and we love working with him and Bellwether!

Devin B.February 2019

Response from Bellwether

This company is amazing! They make you feel very comfortable during the whole process, and ended up save me a substantial amount of money. I will never go anywhere else for my insurance needs.

MERCEDES L.June 2018

Response from Bellwether

Aaron helped me change 2 insurance policies and saved me over $100 a month. Thanks!

Nate H.October 2017

Response from Bellwether

I can't even begin to describe the remarkable service my family and I have received from Bellwether! I have always been hesitant to change my home and Auto Insurance but decided to give this company a chance, and I am glad I did! They saved me a lot of money on both my home and Auto Insurance and at the same time got us better coverage! I only had supply them with some information and they did the rest. It was very easy. They kept me up to date with what was going on and never made a step without contacting myself first! I would definitely recommend Bellwether!

Brenda G.March 2017

Response from Bellwether

Worked with us? Tell others how it went

A Google review takes about a minute and helps Ohio families and business owners find an agency they can trust. We read every one.