About Bellwether Insurance

We're an independent insurance agency in LaGrange, Ohio. Since 2016, we've helped Ohio families and businesses compare coverage with access to dozens of carrier options, and we stay with them through every renewal and claim.

The Bellwether Insurance ram logo on our office window in LaGrange, Ohio
Our office at 100 N. Center Street, LaGrange
2016
Founded in LaGrange, Ohio
Dozens
Carrier options we have access to
5.0
Rating from 84 Google reviews
2
States we're licensed in: Ohio and Georgia

bell·weth·er

noun

  1. The lead ram of a flock, wearing a bell, that the rest of the flock follows.
  2. Something that leads the way and that others look to for direction.

Why we're called Bellwether

Shepherds hung a bell on the ram that led the flock, so they could always hear where it was heading. That ram is on our logo, and the spiral of its horn shows up across this site.

For us, the name is a promise to lead: to know the insurance market well enough to point you to the right coverage before you need it, and to stay out front when something goes wrong.

What working with us looks like

We're a small agency on purpose. You'll know who's handling your policies, and they'll know you.

  • We work for you, not a carrier

    We have access to dozens of carrier options, so our advice isn't tied to any one of them. We compare coverage and price, then recommend the policy that fits, even when that means a carrier you hadn't heard of.

  • One office for your home and your business

    Home, auto, business and life coverage, plus employee benefits, all live under one roof. If you own a business, the same team that insures your shop can make sure your home, cars and family are covered too, with nothing falling between the policies.

  • We're still here at claim time

    Call us first when something goes wrong. We'll tell you what's likely covered, help you file, and stay involved with the carrier until it's settled. That's the part of the job that matters most.

  • We review before you renew

    Coverage that fit three years ago may not fit now. We look at your policies before they renew, and when a rate jumps, we shop it with other carriers instead of letting it ride.

The people you'll talk to

Four licensed agents in one LaGrange office. Call (216) 600-2828 and dial an extension to reach someone directly.

Aaron McElwain

Aaron McElwain, CIC

Co-owner and agency principal

Commercial lines

Aaron leads our commercial lines. Before insurance, he spent 25 years in the automotive and service garage industry, so shop owners, dealers and manufacturers find he already speaks their language. He holds the Certified Insurance Counselor designation.

Sandra McElwain

Sandra McElwain

Co-owner

Personal lines

Sandra co-owns the agency and leads personal lines: home, auto, condo, umbrella and everything else that protects your family. She brings a wealth of industry experience to personalized coverage and outstanding customer service.

Jessica Fox

Jessica Fox

Agent

Personal and small Business Insurance

Jessica helps families and small business owners put the right coverage in place and keep it current as life changes. When she isn't working, she's busy raising her two sons.

Visit our office

Get Directions

Licensed and credentialed

  • Licensed in Ohio and Georgia
  • Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) on staff
  • Access to dozens of carrier options
  • Independently owned in LaGrange since 2016

Where we work

We insure homes, families and businesses across Ohio, with most of our clients close to home in LaGrange, Elyria, Wellington, Grafton, Oberlin, North Ridgeville, Avon and Medina.

See what an independent agency can find for you

Tell us what you want to protect. We'll compare carriers, explain your options in plain English and change nothing until you say so.