About Our Agency

Bellwether Insurance provides comprehensive insurance solutions.

Home » About Our Agency

We are your trusted independent insurance agency.

Your family, your business and your possessions are all important to you, but you may not know how to best protect them. We have the experience to navigate the unique risks you face, serving as your insurance advisor.

We are 100% focused on being a client experience centered organization.

Bellwether Insurance is an independent insurance agency in LaGrange, OH that provides customized insurance solutions with personalized service. We offer personal and business insurance, with some of our specialties in restaurant, dealership, garage repair shop, home and auto insurance.

Because we are an independent agency, we work for you, not the insurance companies. It is our goal to make sure you, your family, your property and your business are properly insured at a reasonable price.

We started Bellwether Insurance on the premise of providing the type of service we expect from the businesses we deal with daily in our personal lives. We believe in providing every client with personalized service rooted in the following core values:

  • Honesty
  • Integrity
  • Courtesy
  • Timeliness

Our goal is to build lifelong relationships through unparalleled customer service and exceptional attention to detail. We are available seven days a week and we’ll respond to your questions and concerns promptly.

Our Specialties

Garage Repair Shop Insurance

Dealership Insurance

Restaurant Insurance

We’re proud to give back to our community and do so in the following ways:

  • We are board members of the local chapter of Lions International, the LaGrange Lions Club.
  • We are members of the Friends of the Keystone-LaGrange Library Club.
  • We support Mastiffs to Mutts large breed dog rescue.
  • We are members of The Black River Astronomical Society.
  • We are members of SIA of Northern Ohio and the Insurance Board of Northern Ohio.
  • We support the National Kidney Foundation.
Start Quote Request

Meet Our Agency Owners

Visit Our Team Page

Aaron McElwain

Sandra McElwain


As an independent insurance agency we have great relationships with many well-known, reputable insurance companies, giving you the power of choice.


Our insurance advisors have years of experience in the insurance industry and serve as your advocate from selecting coverage through filing a claim.


Our insurance advisors have a strong passion for insurance and protecting what you value most in business and in life. We treat our customers like family.

At Bellwether Insurance, our mission is very simple. We strive to provide a true, concierge client experience which is unique in the insurance industry. We give clients the power of choice from top-rated national and regional insurance carriers.

Insurance Quote Request

As an independent agency, we offer multiple options at competitive prices.

  • Coverage will not be bound or changed until confirmed by a licensed agent.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.